
Hoka
Better than Brooks Cascadia Elite at:
- A higher overall score (91 vs 87)
- A lighter option (8 g less)
- Deeper lugs for grip (4 vs 3.5 mm)


What changes on your runs
Brooks Cascadia Elite
$274.95
The better pick if you want:
Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak
$290
No clear advantage on the specs we track.
Each axis ranks against the 177 products in Shoes on the site: the further out, the more it stands out in that spec (lighter, cheaper…).
Center: lowest in the category · Edge: highest
Brooks Cascadia Elite· leads in 2
Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak· leads in 1
Tied
Cushioning
Lightness
Grip
Drophigher isn't better or worse
Affordability
Compare features between Brooks Cascadia Elite vs Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak
How Brooks Cascadia Elite vs Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak should behave on each kind of ground, estimated from lug depth, stack height, weight and outsole rubber. Pick a ground to see what decides it.
| Pick a ground | Average | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 56 | |||||||
| 55 |
Cushioning and low weight make the kilometres easier; very deep lugs squirm on hard ground.
A model built from the specs to compare shoes, not a lab measurement.

Help the community by answering

Help the community by answering
Watch real-world YouTube reviews from content creators and the Trail Running community.
See the differences between Brooks Cascadia Elite and Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak in a side-by-side slider comparison.
Answers based on product data and key differences.
Can't find what you're looking for? Ask anything about Brooks Cascadia Elite vs Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak and our AI will answer.
For value comparison: The Brooks Cascadia Elite ($275) offers better affordability compared to the Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak ($290). Consider your budget and the specific features that matter most for your trail running setup.
The Merrell MTL Speedarc Peak is newer: it came out in July 2026, and the Brooks Cascadia Elite in March 2026.
Closest in price, with what each one does better.

Hoka
Better than Brooks Cascadia Elite at:

Norda
Better than Brooks Cascadia Elite at: